ORDER INSTRUCTIONS: Choose your pickup date (must be at least 48 hours after the order is placed), and add to your cart. Then fill out the form and let us know which pie you’d like us to make!

We currently offer 7 ice cream pie options (Photos below):

Aggie: The Aggie Pie starts with an Oreo crust, followed by peanut butter soft serve, vanilla soft serve, hot fudge, peanut butter sauce and puppy chow. Topped with mini buckeyes, mini chocolate chips and chocolate whipped cream.

Margot: The Margot Pie starts with an Oreo crust, followed by chocolate soft serve, vanilla soft serve, hot fudge and Oreo cookie crumble. Topped with cookies-and-cream whipped cream.

Myra: The Myra Pie starts with an Oreo crust, followed by chocolate soft serve, vanilla soft serve, hot fudge, mini mint chips and mint-chocolate cookie crumble. Topped with mint whipped cream.

Ruby: Our Ruby Pie starts with a graham cracker crust, followed by strawberry soft serve, vanilla soft serve, strawberry compote, candied pretzel crunch and strawberry-shortcake crumble. Topped with strawberry whipped cream.

Lola: Our Lola Pie starts with a graham cracker crust, followed by vanilla soft serve, key lime curd and graham cracker crumble. Topped with lime curd and vanilla whipped cream.

Daisy: The Daisy Pie starts with a graham cracker crust, followed by strawberry soft serve, vanilla soft serve, chopped circus animal cookies, birthday cake crumble, lemon buttercream and Funfetti sprinkles. Topped with strawberry whipped cream.

Sadie (Online Only): The Sadie Pie starts with a graham cracker crust, followed by vanilla soft serve, peanut butter-marshmallow fluff, Snickers bits, hot fudge, maple bourbon caramel, chopped peanuts and chocolate ganache.

If you would like us to use our Dairy Free Vanilla, please let us know on the order form when checking out. There will be an extra $4 charge upon pickup.